How Some Filipinos Are Using Insurance as an Investment Strategy—Smart or a Scam?

Many Filipinos are exploring insurance policies not just for protection, but also as a way to grow their money. But is this a smart move, or are they falling for something that sounds too good to be true? Let’s break down how insurance as an investment works in the Philippines, look at the pros and cons, and help you decide if it’s the right strategy for you.

What Exactly is Insurance as an Investment?

Traditionally, insurance is about protecting yourself and your loved ones from financial hardship if something bad happens – like illness, accidents, or even death. You pay premiums, and in return, the insurance company promises to pay out a certain amount in case of a covered event. But insurance companies offer products that combine this protection with an investment component. These are often called Variable Unit Linked (VUL) insurance policies.

VULs are basically life insurance policies where a portion of your premium goes towards life insurance coverage, and the rest is invested in various funds, often stocks or bonds. The value of your investment then fluctuates based on the performance of these funds. This means your cash value can grow over time, potentially giving you a return on your investment alongside the insurance coverage.

How Does VUL Insurance Actually Work?

Let’s paint a more detailed picture. Say you purchase a VUL policy. A percentage of your premium gets allocated to cover the cost of the insurance itself (things like death benefit). Then, the remaining portion of your payment goes into investment funds of your choice. You might choose a low-risk fund that invests mainly in bonds, or a higher-risk fund that invests more aggressively in stocks. The insurer charges fees for managing these funds and the insurance coverage. As your chosen investments grow (or shrink!), the cash value of your VUL policy also grows (or shrinks!). You can usually withdraw from this cash value, though there might be penalties, especially in the early years of the policy.

The value of the investment component is tied to the market’s performance. If the market does well, your investment grows. If the market goes down, your investment goes down. So, it’s vital to understand that there’s a risk of losing money. It’s not a guaranteed return like a savings account, but it offers the potential for higher growth over time.

Why Are Filipinos Interested in Insurance as an Investment?

Several factors contribute to the growing interest in using insurance as an investment vehicle among Filipinos.

• Financial Literacy Initiatives: There’s increasing awareness regarding financial planning and investing. Many Filipinos are actively seeking ways to grow their wealth beyond traditional savings accounts. Seminars, online courses, and social media content are making investment concepts more accessible.
• Low Interest Rates: Traditional savings offer limited returns. With interest rates on savings accounts often struggling to keep up with inflation, Filipinos are looking for options that provide better potential growth.
• Ease of Access: It can be perceived as easier to invest through insurance than to open a brokerage account and manage investments directly. Some find the advice of insurance agents helpful in navigating investment options.
• Forced Savings Mentality: The regular premium payments can act as a forced savings mechanism. For those who struggle to save consistently, this provides a structured approach.
• Perceived Tax Advantages: Some insurance policies offer tax advantages. For example, the death benefit paid to beneficiaries is generally tax-free. There may also be tax advantages associated with the accumulated cash value, although the specifics can vary.

The Potential Benefits of Insurance as an Investment

While caution is necessary, there are potential benefits to using insurance as an investment tool.

• Life Insurance Protection: You get life insurance coverage. This provides a safety net for your family if something happens to you. The death benefit can help cover living expenses, education costs, or other financial needs.

Follow us on LinkedIn!



• Potential for Investment Growth: If the investment funds perform well, your policy’s cash value can grow significantly over time. This can help you reach your financial goals, such as retirement or funding your children’s education.
• Disciplined Savings: The regular premium payments encourage a consistent savings habit. This can be particularly helpful for those who find it difficult to save on their own.
• Professional Management: The insurance company manages the investment funds for you. This can be beneficial if you don’t have the time or knowledge to manage your own investments. However, remember that you’re paying them fees for this service.

The Potential Drawbacks and Risks

It’s crucial to be aware of the potential downsides before diving into VULs. These are not without risks and potential disadvantages.

• High Fees: Insurance policies often come with substantial fees, including premium charges, fund management fees, surrender charges (if you cancel the policy early), and other administrative costs. These fees can significantly eat into your investment returns.
• Complex Products: VULs can be complex and difficult to understand fully. This can make it challenging to assess the true cost and potential benefits.
• Market Risk: As with any investment, there’s a risk that your investment will lose value. The performance of the investment funds depends on market conditions, which can fluctuate significantly. During economic downturns, your cash value could decrease substantially.
• Surrender Charges: If you need to withdraw your money early (surrender the policy), you may face hefty surrender charges. These charges can significantly reduce the amount of money you receive, particularly in the early years of the policy.
• Opportunity Cost: The money you put into an insurance policy could potentially be invested elsewhere (directly in stocks or bonds) with lower fees and potentially higher returns.
• Long-Term Commitment: To see the full benefits of an insurance policy as an investment, you typically need to commit to it for a long period. If you need access to your money sooner than expected, you may face penalties or lower returns.
• Inflation Risk: The returns on your investment may not keep pace with inflation. This means that the purchasing power of your money could decrease over time.
• Insurance Agent Bias: Insurance agents often earn commissions on the policies they sell. This can create a bias towards selling policies that benefit them financially, rather than what’s necessarily the best option for you. It’s vital to do your own research and consult with other financial advisors if necessary.

Real-World Considerations and Examples in the Philippines

Let’s consider some specific scenarios relevant to Filipinos.

Example 1: The OFW Perspective. Many Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs) are targeted with VUL policies, often sold with the promise of high returns and financial security. While the intention is good, it’s crucial that OFWs carefully analyze the fees and potential returns, comparing them to other investment options available to them. Some platforms offer global investment accounts with lower fees allowing OFWs to invest directly. Furthermore, OFWs should assess if the life insurance coverage is truly necessary, given that they might already have coverage in their host country or that their families may have other sources of income.

Example 2: The Young Professional. A young professional starting their career might be attracted to VULs due to the perceived ease of investment. However, they may be better off investing smaller amounts in a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds through a low-cost broker, focusing on building a solid financial foundation before committing to a long-term insurance policy with potentially high fees.

Example 3: The Retiree. A retiree might be lured by the promise of guaranteed income from an insurance policy. However, it’s vital to assess the stability and financial strength of the insurance company, and to compare the potential income stream with other retirement income options, such as annuities or withdrawals from a retirement fund.

There’s been quite a bit of talk and even some controversies regarding these plans in the Philippines. For example, some Filipinos have reported feeling pressured by insurance agents to purchase VULs without fully understanding the terms. It’s important to remember that insurance agents are sales people and while some are genuinely helpful, there is a sales target that they need to achieve. There have also been cases where the actual returns of VUL policies fell far short of the initial projections. These experiences highlight the importance of due diligence, critical thinking, and independent financial advice.

Warning Signs: How to Spot a Potential “Scam” (or Just a Bad Deal)

While not all insurance-as-investment policies are scams, some are definitely better deals than others. Here’s what to look out for:

• Overly Aggressive Sales Tactics: If the insurance agent is pushing you extremely hard, making you feel pressured to sign up immediately without giving you time to think it over, that’s a red flag. A good advisor will understand that you need time to consider your options.
• Unrealistic Returns: Be wary of promises of guaranteed high returns. Investments always involve risk, and no one can guarantee a specific return. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
• Lack of Transparency: If the agent is unable or unwilling to explain the fees, charges, and investment options clearly, be suspicious. You have the right to understand exactly where your money is going and how it’s being used.
• Focus on Investment, Not Insurance: If the agent is primarily focused on the investment aspect and downplays the insurance coverage, it might not be the right product for your needs. Remember the primary purpose of insurance is protection against risk.
• Complex Jargon You Don’t Understand: If the policy documents are filled with complicated financial terms that you don’t fully grasp, ask for clarification. Don’t sign anything unless you understand it completely.
• Pressure to Switch Existing Policies: Be very cautious about replacing an existing insurance policy with a new one. This could result in you losing benefits or paying higher fees. Always compare the pros and cons carefully.

Alternatives to Insurance as an Investment

Before committing to an insurance policy as an investment, consider alternative options that might be more suitable for your financial goals.

• Direct Investments in Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Opening a brokerage account and investing directly in stocks, bonds, or mutual funds allows you to have more control over your investments and often involves lower fees. In the Philippines, there are apps and platforms that make investing directly in the stock market accessible to beginners
• Time Deposits: Time deposits offer a relatively safe and predictable return. While the returns may be lower than some other investments, they provide a guaranteed interest rate for a fixed period.
• Government Securities: Investing in government securities, such as treasury bills or bonds, is a relatively safe way to earn interest on your money.
• Real Estate: Real estate can be a good long-term investment. However, it requires a significant capital outlay and involves ongoing management responsibilities. Be mindful of property taxes and unforeseen maintenance.
• Pag-IBIG MP2: The Pag-IBIG MP2 Savings Program is a voluntary savings program for Pag-IBIG members that offers higher dividend rates than regular Pag-IBIG savings. It’s backed by the government, making it a relatively safe investment option. Many Filipinos who are risk averse use this as an effective way to save and grow their funds.
• Business Ventures: Starting your own business can offer the potential for high returns, but it also comes with significant risks and requires hard work and dedication.

Questions to Ask Before Buying an Insurance Policy as an Investment

If you’re considering buying an insurance policy as an investment, be sure to ask these crucial questions:

1. What are all the fees and charges associated with the policy? (Get a detailed breakdown of premium charges, fund management fees, surrender charges, and other administrative costs.)
2. How are the investment funds managed? (Who is managing the funds, what is their investment strategy, and what is their track record?)
3. What are the risks involved in the investment? (Understand the potential for loss and how the market’s volatility might impact your cash value.)
4. What are the surrender charges if I cancel the policy early? (Find out how much you’ll lose if you need to withdraw your money before the policy matures.)
5. What is the death benefit, and how does it compare to other life insurance policies? (Ensure that the life insurance coverage is adequate for your needs.)
6. Can I see projections of the potential returns based on different market scenarios? (Understand that these are just projections and not guarantees.)
7. What are the tax implications of this policy? (Consult with a tax advisor to understand how the policy will affect your tax liability.)
8. Is this policy suitable for my financial goals and risk tolerance? (Consider your individual circumstances and whether the policy aligns with your overall financial plan.)
9. What are the specific investment options available and how are they performing? (Request fact sheets detailing the fund’s mandate, historical performance, and expense ratio.)
10. What are the specific qualifications and credentials of the financial advisor/ insurance agent providing the advice? (Ensure they have the pertinent knowledge and experience to advise you.)

Who is this Insurance “Investment” For?

Insurance as an investment isn’t for everyone. It might be suitable for:

• Individuals who need life insurance coverage and are also looking for an investment component. If you need life insurance anyway, it can be a way to combine protection and potential growth.
• Those who are comfortable with moderate risk and have a long-term investment horizon. It’s not a get-rich-quick scheme. The best time horizon is typically 10 years or more.
• Individuals who prefer professional management of their investments. If you do not have the knowledge or time to actively manage an investment portfolio, a VUL might provide access to professionally managed funds.
• Those who value the disciplined savings aspect of regular premium payments. If you struggle to save consistently on your own, the forced savings aspect can be helpful.

However, it might not be suitable for:

• Individuals who are risk-averse and need a guaranteed return on their investment. If protecting your capital is your main priority, safer investments like time deposits might be preferable.
• Those who need access to their money in the short term. The surrender charges can be prohibitive if you need to withdraw your money early.
• Individuals who are comfortable managing their own investments. If you’re willing to take the time to learn about investing and manage your own portfolio, you can often achieve better returns with lower fees.
• Those who are easily pressured by sales people. Take all recommendations with a grain of salt and independently verify all information.

Understanding the Impact of Fees

Let’s really talk about fees. High fees can destroy returns. Imagine you are investing Php10,000 per month. After 20 years, if your fees are 1% per year, you may have about Php 3 million. If your fees are 3% per year, you may end up with around Php 2.3 million. That’s a difference of Php 700,000!

Fees in VULs can come in many forms, and it’s important to understand them.

Premium Charges are deducted directly from your premium payments. These are used to cover the insurance company’s administrative costs and sales commissions.
Fund Management Fees are charged by the investment managers for managing the funds in which your policy is invested.
Mortality Charges covers the cost of the life insurance. As you grow older, this cost increases.
Policy Fees: Some policies have a fixed annual or monthly fee.
Surrender Charges are charged if you cancel the policy before maturity.

These all need to be taken into account when evaluating the potential returns of a VUL.

Keep in mind also that these fees will be charged whether you are making money or losing money.

The Philippine Context: Regulatory Oversight

The Insurance Commission (IC) of the Philippines is the government agency responsible for regulating and supervising the insurance industry. The IC aims to protect the interests of insurance policyholders and ensure the financial stability of insurance companies. You can visit their website to learn more about regulations and consumer protection tips. While they do provide oversight, it is still up to you to perform due diligence.

Making an Informed Decision

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to use insurance as an investment is a personal one. There is no one size fits all approach. Carefully weigh the pros and cons and consider your own financial circumstances, goals, and risk tolerance. Don’t be afraid to seek out independent financial advice from a qualified professional who is not affiliated with an insurance company. Remember, the key is to make an informed decision that aligns with your overall financial plan.

FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is VUL insurance a scam?
A: It’s not necessarily a scam, but it’s not always the best investment. It’s a combination of insurance and investment, and if you understand the fees and risks, it can be a valid choice. However, high fees can eat into returns, and it may not be the best option for everyone.

Q: Can I lose money in a VUL policy?
A: Yes. The investment part of a VUL is subject to market fluctuations. If the investment funds perform poorly, you could lose money.

Q: What happens if I can’t afford to pay my VUL premiums?
A: If you stop paying your premiums, your insurance coverage will lapse, and you may lose the money you’ve invested, especially if surrender charges are high. Some policies have a grace period before the policy lapses, or they may allow you to reduce your coverage to lower your premium

Q: Can I withdraw money from my VUL policy?
A: Yes, but there may be surrender charges, especially in the early years of the policy. Check the policy details for specific rules and fees. Withdrawing money will also reduce your cash value and potentially your death benefit.

Q: How do I choose the right investment options within my VUL policy?
A: Consider your risk tolerance and financial goals. If you are risk averse, choose more conservative options like bonds, while if you are comfortable with more risk, you might choose stocks. You can ask your insurance agent for guidance. However, it is wise for you to do independent research for each fund.

Q: Is death benefit from a VUL tax-free?
A: Generally, yes. The death benefit paid to your beneficiaries is usually tax-free under Philippine law. However, it’s always best to consult with a tax professional for personalized advice.

Q: How do I know if my insurance agent is giving me good advice?
A: Do your own research. Don’t rely solely on the agent’s recommendations. Compare different policies and investment options. Seek independent financial advice from a fee-based advisor who doesn’t earn commissions on insurance sales.

Q: If I’m young, should I still consider getting VUL insurance?
A: If you need life insurance and are comfortable with the long-term commitment, it can be an option. However, consider that younger people tend to have a long investment horizon and may benefit more from other investment vehicles. They can invest directly in low cost index funds.

References

These are references that could be linked to the article but are included here as a list only.

• Insurance Commission of the Philippines (for regulations)
• Securities and Exchange Commission (for investment information)
• Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (for information on interest rates and inflation)
• Pag-IBIG Fund (for information on MP2 Savings Program)

Ready to Take Control of Your Financial Future?

Now you’re armed with the knowledge to make a smart decision about insurance as an investment. Don’t rush into anything. Thoroughly research your options, compare different policies, and understand the fees and risks involved. If you’re considering a VUL, get a second opinion from a trusted financial advisor. And remember, the best investment is one that aligns with your individual goals and risk tolerance.
If you’re still unsure, exploring alternative options like low-cost index funds or government-backed savings programs could be a less risky way to grow your money. The key is to start somewhere and to continuously learn and adapt your financial strategy as your circumstances change.