Questioning a Philippine Real Estate Appraisal Value

Think the appraisal of your Philippine property is too low (or too high)? Don’t just accept it! Understanding why an appraisal matters and how to challenge it can potentially save you a lot of money, whether you’re selling, buying, or even just refinancing.

What’s an Appraisal, Anyway?

Let’s imagine you’re selling your beautiful bungalow in Batangas. You think it’s worth ₱5 million, but the bank appraisal comes back at ₱4 million. Yikes! That’s an appraisal – a professional opinion of your property’s market value. It’s usually done by licensed appraisers, and lenders (like banks) rely on it to decide how much money they’re willing to lend to a buyer. Basically, they want to make sure the property is worth what they’re lending!

Why Does That Appraisal Number Matter?

This number is super important for several reasons. If you’re selling, a lower appraisal can mean buyers can’t get as big of a loan, potentially killing the sale or forcing you to lower your asking price. If you’re buying, a low appraisal might mean you need to cough up more cash for a down payment. And if you’re refinancing, a low appraisal could stop you from getting the loan terms you want. Imagine trying to refinance your condo in Makati to take advantage of lower interest rates, only to be told the property’s valued less than you thought. It’s frustrating, right?

Is the Appraisal Final? Can You Question It?

Good news! Appraisal values aren’t set in stone. You, as the property owner (or potential buyer), have the right to question the appraisal if you believe it’s inaccurate. But before you start firing off angry emails, it’s vital to understand how appraisals work and build a solid case.

Understanding How Appraisals Work in the Philippines

Appraisers look at various factors to determine a property’s value. Here’s a simplified breakdown:

• Location, Location, Location: Just like anywhere else, location is king (or queen!) in the Philippines. A house in a prime area of Ayala Alabang will naturally be worth more than a similar house further away. Consider accessibility to transport, schools, hospitals, and commercial centers.
• Comparable Sales (Comps): Appraisers examine recent sales of similar properties (comps) in the area. They adjust for differences in size, features, condition, and location. For example, if a comparable property had a swimming pool and yours doesn’t, the appraiser will adjust the price downward.
• Property Condition: Is your property well-maintained, or does it need some serious TLC? A newly renovated kitchen or bathroom can significantly increase the value, while a leaky roof or termite infestation can drag it down.

Follow us on LinkedIn!



• Property Size and Features: The size of your lot and the size of the house (floor area) are crucial. Features like the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, a garage, a garden, or a swimming pool all contribute to the property’s overall value.
• The Overall Market: Is it a buyer’s market or a seller’s market? Are property prices rising or falling in your area? Economic factors influence property values.

So, before you challenge an appraisal, ask yourself: how does my property stack up against these factors?

Why Might an Appraisal Be Inaccurate?

Several things can lead to an inaccurate appraisal. Here’s the lowdown:

• Inaccurate Comps: Maybe the appraiser used comparable sales that weren’t truly comparable. Perhaps they included a property that was distressed sale (sold quickly at a lower price due to financial difficulties) or a property with very different features.
• Missed Features or Improvements: Did the appraiser fail to notice the brand-new solar panels you installed or the fact that you recently upgraded the electrical wiring? Missing these details can undervalue your property.
• Errors in Measurement: A mistake in the property’s square footage can significantly impact the value.
• Outdated Data: Using stale information about market conditions or comparable sales can lead to an inaccurate appraisal. The real estate market can change quickly!
• Appraiser Bias: While rare, it’s possible that appraiser bias could influence the valuation. It is important to remember that appraisers are human.

Steps to Questioning a Philippine Real Estate Appraisal Value

Okay, you’ve reviewed the appraisal report and you’re convinced it’s wrong. Here’s what you should do:

1. Review the Appraisal Report Carefully

Don’t just skim it! Read every page and look for anything that seems off. Pay close attention to the comparable sales used, the property description, and any adjustments made by the appraiser. This document is your foundation.

2. Gather Your Supporting Evidence

This is where the work comes in. You need to build a solid case to support your claim that the appraisal is inaccurate. Here’s what you might need:

• More Accurate Comps: Find recent sales of properties that are truly comparable to yours. Focus on properties in your immediate neighborhood with similar size, features, and condition. Websites like Lamudi and ZipMatch can be helpful, but be sure to verify the sale prices with official sources.
• Documentation of Improvements: Gather receipts, permits, and photos of any renovations or improvements you’ve made to your property. This is crucial to demonstrate the value you’ve added.
• Evidence of Errors: If you find errors in the property description or square footage, provide documentation to correct them. For example, you can provide a copy of your property title (TCT) showing the correct land area.
• Independent Opinion (Optional): Consider getting a second opinion from another licensed real estate professional. A broker or another appraiser (although this may incur a cost) can provide valuable insights.

3. Write a Formal Rebuttal Letter

Don’t just call the lender or appraiser and complain. Write a formal letter outlining your concerns and providing your supporting evidence. Here are some tips for writing an effective rebuttal letter:

• Be Respectful and Professional: Even if you’re frustrated, maintain a respectful tone. Avoid accusations or personal attacks.
• Be Specific: Don’t make vague statements. Clearly identify the specific errors or omissions in the appraisal report.
• Present Your Evidence Clearly: Organize your supporting evidence in a logical and easy-to-understand format. Use bullet points or numbered lists to highlight key information.
• State Your Desired Outcome: Clearly state what you want to happen. Do you want the appraisal to be reviewed? Do you want a new appraisal to be conducted?

Address the letter to the lender or the appraisal management company (AMC), and send a copy to the appraiser. Keep a copy for your records.

4. Submit Your Rebuttal to the Lender

Submit your rebuttal letter and supporting documentation to the lender. The lender is responsible for reviewing your concerns and determining whether the appraisal should be reconsidered or a new appraisal should be ordered.

5. Be Patient and Persistent

The review process can take time. Be patient, but don’t be afraid to follow up with the lender to check on the status of your rebuttal. If the lender rejects your rebuttal, ask for a written explanation of their decision. Depending on the reason, you might want to appeal the decision further, or consider seeking legal advice.

Examples of Effective Rebuttal Points

Let’s say you’re questioning the appraisal of your house in Tagaytay. Here are some examples of rebuttal points you could use:

• “The appraisal report states that the property has no views of Taal Lake. However, the property has unobstructed views of Taal Lake from the living room and master bedroom. I have attached photos as evidence.” This is effective because it points out a specific, verifiable error.
• “The comparable sale used for 123 Example Street is not a true comparable. That property is a distressed sale and was sold at a significantly lower price than market value. I have attached documentation showing that the property was foreclosed upon.” This is effective because it explains why the comparable sale is unreliable.
• “The appraisal report does not reflect the recent renovation of the kitchen and bathrooms. These renovations included new appliances and fixtures and significantly increased the value of the property. I have attached receipts and photos of the renovations.” This is effective because it provides documentation to support the claim that the property has been improved.

The Cost of Questioning an Appraisal

Questioning an appraisal doesn’t necessarily cost you anything upfront. However, if you decide to get a second opinion from another appraiser, you’ll need to pay for that appraisal. The cost can vary depending on the property type and location, but you can expect to pay several thousand pesos for a new appraisal. For instance, one appraisal service in Metro Manila charges fees depending on the property evaluated.

Important Considerations

• Time is of the Essence: Don’t delay in questioning the appraisal. The sooner you act, the better your chances of getting a revised appraisal.
• Keep Detailed Records: Keep copies of all correspondence, documentation, and receipts related to the appraisal.
• Understand Your Rights: Familiarize yourself with your rights as a property owner. While you are not entitled to an appraiser of your choosing in loan transactions, you are entitled to a copy of the appraisal report per the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) guidelines.

The Role of a Real Estate Professional

Dealing with appraisals can be tricky. Consider enlisting the help of a qualified real estate professional, especially if you are not familiar with property values. Agents often can provide comparative market analysis data which lists recent sold properties that match the criteria in question. Remember this is for your knowledge only and to help you prepare a rebuttal. Also, appraisers, particularly those accredited by reputable organizations such as the Philippine Association of Real Estate Boards (PAREB) usually adhere to certain standards.

FAQ Section

Here are some commonly asked questions about challenging real estate appraisals in the Philippines:

Q: Who pays for the appraisal?

A: Typically, the buyer pays for the appraisal when they are obtaining a mortgage. However, if you are refinancing your existing loan, you will usually be responsible for the appraisal fee.

Q: How long does an appraisal take?

A: The time it takes to complete an appraisal can vary depending on the complexity of the property and the appraiser’s workload. Generally, it takes about one to two weeks from the time the appraisal is ordered to the time the report is delivered.

Q: Can I choose my own appraiser?

A: This depends on the situation. Usually, the bank or lender commissions the appraiser. In loan transactions, lenders often must maintain independence from undue influence from any party. As a buyer, technically you do not have the right to choose your own appraiser when getting a loan. However, if you’re just curious about your property’s value, you can hire an independent appraiser yourself.

Q: What happens if the appraisal is still too low after I challenge it?

A: If your rebuttal is unsuccessful, you have a few options. You could try negotiating with the buyer (if you’re the seller) or increasing your down payment (if you’re the buyer). You might also consider walking away from the deal if the appraisal is significantly lower than what you believe the property is worth. If you are applying for a loan you could also seek a second opinion from another financial institution.

Q: Where can I find a licensed real estate appraiser in the Philippines?

A: You can find licensed real estate appraisers through the Professional Regulation Commission (PRC) or through reputable real estate organizations like PAREB. Always verify the appraiser’s license and credentials before hiring them. You can also ask your insurance broker for recommendations.

Q: What if I’m selling my property ‘cash’? Does an appraisal still matter?

A: Even if the transaction is ‘cash’, an appraisal is still an excellent way to make sure you’re not underpricing your property. A potential buyer would want to verify the current market pricing as well.

References

• Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
• Lamudi Philippines
• ZipMatch
• Philippine Association of Real Estate Boards (PAREB)

Don’t let a questionable appraisal derail your real estate plans! Take the time to understand how appraisals work, gather your evidence, and challenge the valuation if you believe it’s inaccurate. It’s your right, and it could save you thousands of pesos. If you feel lost or overwhelmed at any point, consult with a trusted real estate professional for guidance. Now, go out there and get the value you deserve!